---
title: How to negotiate a job offer without losing it | Hollis & Reed
description: Almost every offer has room in it. Here is how to ask for more, what to ask for, and when to stop.
image: https://www.nopethemes.com/hubfs/recruiting-demo/meeting-advisers-desk.jpg
---

[Skip to main content](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog/how-to-negotiate-a-job-offer#main-content)

[![](https://www.nopethemes.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/studionope-for-recruiting/images/brand/hollis-reed-mark.svg) **Hollis & Reed**](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/home)

- [Find jobs](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/jobs)
- [Hire talent](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/employers)
- [Specialisms](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/specialisms)
- [Salary guide](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/salary-guide)
- [About](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/about)

[Upload your CV](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/candidates) [Request talent](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/employers)

- [Find jobs](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/jobs)
- [Hire talent](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/employers)
- [Specialisms](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/specialisms)
- [Salary guide](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/salary-guide)
- [About](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/about)

[Upload your CV](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/candidates)[Request talent](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/employers)

[Salary](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog/tag/salary)·4 min read

# How to negotiate a job offer without losing it

![](https://www.nopethemes.com/hs-fs/hubfs/recruiting-demo/staff-04.jpg?width=48&height=48&name=staff-04.jpg) [Ashley Carter](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog/author/hollis-reed-ashley-carter)·October 27, 2026

![How to negotiate a job offer without losing it](https://www.nopethemes.com/hubfs/recruiting-demo/meeting-advisers-desk.jpg)

Hollis & Reed handled a little over 1,100 offers last year across finance, healthcare, operations and technology roles. Fewer than one in a hundred was withdrawn because the candidate asked for more. The few that were had something in common: the candidate asked late, asked several times, or asked in a way that sounded like a threat. Asking well is a skill, and most of it happens before the phone call.

## Know the range before the call

You can't ask for a sensible number if you don't know what the role pays. Look at three sources: what similar roles in your city advertise, what people in your network have been paid recently, and a salary guide built from real offers. Ours is on the [salary guide page](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/salary-guide) and is updated every quarter from placements we have made in the Chicago area.

Work out three numbers before the offer arrives. Your target is a number near the top of the range that you can justify. Your acceptable number is the one you would sign at today. Your walk-away number is the one below which you would turn the job down. Write all three down. People who skip this step tend to anchor on whatever the employer offers first.

## Ask once, for everything

When the offer comes, thank them, say you are excited about the role, and ask for a day or two to look at the full package. Then come back with one conversation that covers everything you want to change. Base salary, signing bonus, start date, remote days, title and vacation all belong in the same request.

Coming back three separate times, first about salary, then the bonus, then vacation, is the most common way candidates damage an offer. Each round makes the hiring manager wonder what the next request will be, and it reads as if the role itself matters less than the deal.

| Item | Often movable? | What to ask |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Base salary | Usually, 3 to 8% | A specific number with a reason |
| Signing bonus | Often | Cover a bonus you lose by leaving |
| Start date | Almost always | Two to four weeks, or a short break |
| Remote days | Depends on team | One extra day, after 90 days |
| Vacation | Sometimes | Five extra days if salary is fixed |
| Title | Rarely | Only if the scope clearly fits |

## Give a reason and offer a trade

A number with a reason is far easier to approve than a number on its own. "My current base is $91,000 and I would lose a $6,000 bonus that pays out in March. Could you get to $98,000?" gives the hiring manager something to take to finance. "I was hoping for more" gives them nothing.

Trades help too. "If you can get to $98,000, I can start on the 3rd instead of the 17th" makes it easy to say yes, because you are giving something back. If base salary is fixed by a pay band, which is common in hospitals and large companies, ask what else is flexible. A signing bonus or an earlier review date often comes from a different budget.

> "I don't mind a candidate asking. I mind a candidate asking four times." — Laura Kim, head of people

## Know when to stop

When the answer comes back as "this is our best offer", it usually is. At that point you have two choices: accept the offer in front of you, or turn it down. Pushing again rarely moves the number and often costs goodwill with the person who will be your manager.

A few other things to avoid:

- Don't invent a competing offer. Recruiters and hiring managers hear this often and some will ask to see it.
- Don't accept verbally and then reopen the terms by email. Once you say yes, the negotiation is over.
- Don't resign from your current job until you have the new offer in writing and any background check has cleared.

If you are working with one of our consultants, let them make the ask. We know what this employer has agreed to before, which items are flexible, and how to phrase the request so it lands well. That is part of the job, and there is no cost to you as a candidate.

Share this post

<https://www.linkedin.com/sharing/share-offsite/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nopethemes.com%2Frecruiting%2Fblog%2Fhow-to-negotiate-a-job-offer> <https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nopethemes.com%2Frecruiting%2Fblog%2Fhow-to-negotiate-a-job-offer> <https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nopethemes.com%2Frecruiting%2Fblog%2Fhow-to-negotiate-a-job-offer> [mailto:?subject=A%20post%20from%20Hollis%20%26%20Reed%20Staffing&body=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nopethemes.com%2Frecruiting%2Fblog%2Fhow-to-negotiate-a-job-offer](mailto:?subject=A%20post%20from%20Hollis%20%26%20Reed%20Staffing&body=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nopethemes.com%2Frecruiting%2Fblog%2Fhow-to-negotiate-a-job-offer)

![](https://www.nopethemes.com/hs-fs/hubfs/recruiting-demo/staff-04.jpg?width=72&height=72&name=staff-04.jpg)

Written by[Ashley Carter](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog/author/hollis-reed-ashley-carter)

Ashley Carter runs the finance desk at Hollis & Reed, Chicago.

## More advice

### [![How to write a CV that gets a call back](https://www.nopethemes.com/hubfs/recruiting-demo/work-laptop-closeup.jpg) CVs · 4 min How to write a CV that gets a call back A hiring manager spends under a minute on a first read. Here is what they look for, in the order they look ...](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog/how-to-write-a-cv-that-gets-a-call-back)

### [![Seven questions to ask at the end of an interview](https://www.nopethemes.com/hubfs/recruiting-demo/meeting-desk-review.jpg) Interviews · 4 min Seven questions to ask at the end of an interview "Do you have any questions for us?" is still part of the interview. These seven tell you more than the job ad ...](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog/questions-to-ask-at-the-end-of-an-interview)

### [![How to hire faster without hiring worse](https://www.nopethemes.com/hubfs/recruiting-demo/meeting-team-table.jpg) Hiring · 4 min How to hire faster without hiring worse Strong candidates are often off the market within two weeks. Five changes that cut weeks from a hiring ...](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog/hire-faster-without-hiring-worse)

[All articles](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog)

## Ready for your next role? Talk to a recruiter.

Send your CV and a recruiter from your field calls you back within one working day.

[Upload your CV →](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/candidates)Or call (312) 555-0148 · Mon–Fri, 8 AM – 6 PM

[![](https://www.nopethemes.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/studionope-for-recruiting/images/brand/hollis-reed-mark.svg) **Hollis & Reed**](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/home)

Recruiting for technology, healthcare, finance and the trades across Chicagoland since 2011.

Candidates

- [Find jobs](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/jobs)
- [Upload your CV](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/candidates)
- [Salary guide](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/salary-guide)
- [Career advice](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog)

Employers

- [Request talent](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/employers)
- [Contract staffing](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/employers#fees)
- [Executive search](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/employers#fees)
- [Fees](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/employers#fees)

Specialisms

- [Technology](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/specialism)
- [Healthcare](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/specialisms)
- [Construction](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/specialisms)
- [Finance](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/specialisms)

Company

- [About](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/about)
- [Recruiters](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/recruiters)
- [Reviews](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/home#reviews)
- [Contact](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/contact)

© 2026 Hollis & Reed Staffing. Demo content.

[Privacy](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/legal#privacy)·[Terms](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/legal#terms)·[Equal opportunity](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/legal#equal-opportunity)

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Ashley Carter",
    "url" : "https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog/author/hollis-reed-ashley-carter"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-11-17T18:35:54.990Z",
  "datePublished" : "2026-10-27T14:00:00.000Z",
  "headline" : "How to negotiate a job offer without losing it | Hollis & Reed",
  "image" : [ "https://www.nopethemes.com/hubfs/recruiting-demo/meeting-advisers-desk.jpg" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog/how-to-negotiate-a-job-offer",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://www.nopethemes.com/hubfs/studio-nope-themes-logo.png"
    }
  }
}
```