---
title: How to hire faster without hiring worse | Hollis & Reed
description: Strong candidates are often off the market within two weeks. Five changes that cut weeks from a hiring process.
image: https://www.nopethemes.com/hubfs/recruiting-demo/meeting-team-table.jpg
---

[Skip to main content](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog/hire-faster-without-hiring-worse#main-content)

[![](https://www.nopethemes.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/studionope-for-recruiting/images/brand/hollis-reed-mark.svg) **Hollis & Reed**](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/home)

- [Find jobs](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/jobs)
- [Hire talent](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/employers)
- [Specialisms](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/specialisms)
- [Salary guide](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/salary-guide)
- [About](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/about)

[Upload your CV](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/candidates) [Request talent](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/employers)

- [Find jobs](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/jobs)
- [Hire talent](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/employers)
- [Specialisms](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/specialisms)
- [Salary guide](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/salary-guide)
- [About](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/about)

[Upload your CV](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/candidates)[Request talent](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/employers)

[Hiring](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog/tag/hiring)·4 min read

# How to hire faster without hiring worse

![](https://www.nopethemes.com/hs-fs/hubfs/recruiting-demo/partners-04.jpg?width=48&height=48&name=partners-04.jpg) [Mark Sullivan](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog/author/hollis-reed-mark-sullivan)·October 20, 2026

![How to hire faster without hiring worse](https://www.nopethemes.com/hubfs/recruiting-demo/meeting-team-table.jpg)

Across the roles we filled in Chicago last year, a strong candidate was typically off the market within ten to fourteen days of starting a search. The average hiring process we see from employers takes about five weeks from first interview to offer. That gap is where most companies lose the people they wanted. Their first choice accepts somewhere else in week three, and they end up offering the job to their second or third choice.

Speed and quality are usually treated as a trade-off. In our experience, the slow processes are rarely more careful. They are just less organized. These five changes cut weeks without lowering the bar.

## Write the scorecard before anyone reads a CV

Get the hiring manager and everyone who will interview into one 30-minute meeting before the role is posted. Agree on three to five things the new hire must be able to do in their first year, written as outcomes. "Close the monthly books in five working days" is useful. "Strong attention to detail" is not.

The scorecard does two things. It lets you screen CVs quickly, because you know what you are looking for. And it stops interviews from drifting into general conversation, which is how teams end up debating gut feelings for a week after the final round.

## Block the interview slots on day one

The single biggest delay we see is calendar time. A hiring manager finds a candidate they like on a Tuesday, and the earliest everyone can meet is two weeks later. By then the candidate has another offer.

Before the role goes live, hold interview slots in every interviewer's calendar for the next three weeks. Two one-hour blocks a week per person is usually enough. If the slots aren't needed, release them. It costs very little and it is the change that most reliably shortens a process.

## Run two rounds, three at most

Most roles can be decided in two rounds:

- **Round one, the work.** A structured conversation with the hiring manager, built on the scorecard. For technical or analytical roles, include a short practical exercise done during the interview. Take-home assignments longer than two hours put off strong candidates who are already employed.
- **Round two, the team.** Two or three future colleagues, back to back on the same day, each covering a different part of the scorecard.

Senior roles may need a third conversation with an executive. Every round beyond that adds about a week and, in our records, rarely changes the decision. If a fourth interview is being requested, it usually means the scorecard wasn't agreed at the start.

> "We went from five rounds to two and our offer acceptance rate went up. Nobody misses the extra interviews." — Tom Reyes, VP of operations

## Decide within 48 hours

Ask every interviewer to submit written feedback against the scorecard on the same day as the interview, before they talk to each other. Then hold a 20-minute debrief the next morning. Written feedback first keeps the loudest voice in the room from setting the outcome.

Tell candidates the decision date at the end of the final interview and keep to it. If the answer is no, say so promptly and kindly. Candidates talk to each other, and a company known for silence after interviews finds it harder to attract people next time.

## Make the offer ready before you need it

Get the salary range, bonus structure and approval chain signed off when the role is opened, not when you find the right person. Offers that wait a week for finance approval lose candidates at the very last step. Know your range by checking current market pay, such as our [salary guide](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/salary-guide), so the first offer is competitive and you avoid a long back and forth.

Call the candidate with the offer, then send it in writing the same day. A verbal offer that takes four days to arrive on paper gives a competing employer time to move.

If you would like help setting up a faster process, our team works with employers on scorecards, interview structure and shortlists. You can read more on the [employers page](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/employers) or call us on (312) 555-0148.

Share this post

<https://www.linkedin.com/sharing/share-offsite/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nopethemes.com%2Frecruiting%2Fblog%2Fhire-faster-without-hiring-worse> <https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nopethemes.com%2Frecruiting%2Fblog%2Fhire-faster-without-hiring-worse> <https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nopethemes.com%2Frecruiting%2Fblog%2Fhire-faster-without-hiring-worse> [mailto:?subject=A%20post%20from%20Hollis%20%26%20Reed%20Staffing&body=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nopethemes.com%2Frecruiting%2Fblog%2Fhire-faster-without-hiring-worse](mailto:?subject=A%20post%20from%20Hollis%20%26%20Reed%20Staffing&body=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nopethemes.com%2Frecruiting%2Fblog%2Fhire-faster-without-hiring-worse)

![](https://www.nopethemes.com/hs-fs/hubfs/recruiting-demo/partners-04.jpg?width=72&height=72&name=partners-04.jpg)

Written by[Mark Sullivan](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog/author/hollis-reed-mark-sullivan)

Mark Sullivan runs the executive search at Hollis & Reed, Chicago.

## More advice

### [![How to write a CV that gets a call back](https://www.nopethemes.com/hubfs/recruiting-demo/work-laptop-closeup.jpg) CVs · 4 min How to write a CV that gets a call back A hiring manager spends under a minute on a first read. Here is what they look for, in the order they look ...](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog/how-to-write-a-cv-that-gets-a-call-back)

### [![Seven questions to ask at the end of an interview](https://www.nopethemes.com/hubfs/recruiting-demo/meeting-desk-review.jpg) Interviews · 4 min Seven questions to ask at the end of an interview "Do you have any questions for us?" is still part of the interview. These seven tell you more than the job ad ...](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog/questions-to-ask-at-the-end-of-an-interview)

### [![How to negotiate a job offer without losing it](https://www.nopethemes.com/hubfs/recruiting-demo/meeting-advisers-desk.jpg) Salary · 4 min How to negotiate a job offer without losing it Almost every offer has room in it. Here is how to ask for more, what to ask for, and when to stop.](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog/how-to-negotiate-a-job-offer)

[All articles](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog)

## Ready for your next role? Talk to a recruiter.

Send your CV and a recruiter from your field calls you back within one working day.

[Upload your CV →](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/candidates)Or call (312) 555-0148 · Mon–Fri, 8 AM – 6 PM

[![](https://www.nopethemes.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/studionope-for-recruiting/images/brand/hollis-reed-mark.svg) **Hollis & Reed**](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/home)

Recruiting for technology, healthcare, finance and the trades across Chicagoland since 2011.

Candidates

- [Find jobs](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/jobs)
- [Upload your CV](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/candidates)
- [Salary guide](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/salary-guide)
- [Career advice](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog)

Employers

- [Request talent](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/employers)
- [Contract staffing](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/employers#fees)
- [Executive search](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/employers#fees)
- [Fees](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/employers#fees)

Specialisms

- [Technology](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/specialism)
- [Healthcare](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/specialisms)
- [Construction](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/specialisms)
- [Finance](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/specialisms)

Company

- [About](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/about)
- [Recruiters](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/recruiters)
- [Reviews](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/home#reviews)
- [Contact](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/contact)

© 2026 Hollis & Reed Staffing. Demo content.

[Privacy](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/legal#privacy)·[Terms](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/legal#terms)·[Equal opportunity](https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/legal#equal-opportunity)

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Mark Sullivan",
    "url" : "https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog/author/hollis-reed-mark-sullivan"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-11-17T18:35:56.464Z",
  "datePublished" : "2026-10-20T14:00:00.000Z",
  "headline" : "How to hire faster without hiring worse | Hollis & Reed",
  "image" : [ "https://www.nopethemes.com/hubfs/recruiting-demo/meeting-team-table.jpg" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://www.nopethemes.com/recruiting/blog/hire-faster-without-hiring-worse",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://www.nopethemes.com/hubfs/studio-nope-themes-logo.png"
    }
  }
}
```